In HBO’s Mare of Easttown, the murder of a teenage mother in a tightly knit Pennsylvania town serves as a catalyst for an unflinching exploration of grief, generational trauma, and the complexities of communal bonds. While the series unfolds as a compelling crime drama, its true resonance lies in its portrayal of how personal loss and collective hardship shape identity and justice in working-class America. Detective Mare Sheehan, portrayed by Kate Winslet, navigates the investigation amidst her own unresolved pain, revealing that the path to truth is as much about confronting internal demons as it is about solving external mysteries.
Critics have lauded the series for its authentic depiction of emotional turmoil and the intricate dynamics within a community where everyone harbors secrets. The show delves into themes of mental illness, substance abuse, and the enduring impact of trauma, illustrating how these issues permeate relationships and influence actions. By focusing on the psychological depth of its characters and the societal pressures they face, Mare of Easttown transcends traditional genre boundaries, offering a narrative that is both poignant and reflective of real-life struggles. This nuanced storytelling invites viewers to consider the profound ways in which personal and collective experiences of pain and resilience are interwoven.
Easttown Case Introductions
In Easttown, Pennsylvania, a working-class suburb of Philadelphia where reputations stick, Detective Marianne “Mare” Sheehan remains a local legend—people still talk about her game-winning shot in the high school basketball championship 25 years ago. When Police Chief Carter (John Douglas Thompson) brings up the year-old missing persons case of Katie Bailey (Caitlin Houlahan)—whose mother, Dawn (Enid Graham), believes the police have given up—Mare bluntly states that the young woman, a known drug user and sex worker, is likely dead. Carter tells Mare the county is sending a detective to assist with the complex case.
Mare lives with her mother, Helen (Jean Smart), her daughter, Siobhan (Angourie Rice), and her four-year-old grandson, Drew (Izzy King). Her cousin, Father Dan Hastings (Neal Huff), is the local Catholic priest. Mare’s ex-husband Frank (David Denman), a high school teacher who remains on good terms with her, is hosting his engagement party at his house, which is located directly behind hers. Still grieving the suicide of her son, Kevin (Cody Kostro), who died two years ago, Mare skips the party to care for Drew.
Seventeen-year-old single mother Erin McMenamin (Cailee Spaeny) has her own struggles. She gets a tense visit from her volatile ex-boyfriend Dylan Hinchey (Jack Mulhern), father of their one-year-old son DJ, and Dylan’s aggressive girlfriend Brianna Delrasso (Mackenzie Lansing). Erin pleads with Dylan to ask his parents for money to cover DJ’s ear surgery. Erin’s grieving father, Kenny (Patrick Murney), whom Erin has cared for since her mother’s recent death from cancer, refuses to lend her the car, suspecting she plans to meet someone he doesn’t trust.
That evening, Mare responds to a break-in at the home of her friend Beth Hanlon (Chinasa Ogbuagu), already aware that the culprit is Beth’s drug-addicted brother, Freddy (Dominique Johnson). After a short chase, Mare convinces Freddy to surrender. The next day, she visits her lifelong best friend, Lori Ross (Julianne Nicholson), and Lori’s family: her husband, John (Joe Tippett); their quiet son, Ryan (Cameron Mann); and their daughter, Moira (Kassie Mundhenk), who has Down syndrome. Mare and Lori make plans for their high school reunion. At the event, Mare meets Richard Ryan (Guy Pearce), a creative writing professor new in town.
Erin confides in her best friend Jess Riley (Ruby Cruz), showing her a photo of someone she plans to meet that night in Sharp’s Woods. Jess is concerned, knowing Dylan and Brianna will also be there. Erin admits she texted Dylan about the meetup, hoping to make him jealous. In the woods, Erin realizes the meeting was a cruel setup by Brianna, who brutally beats her while other teens record the attack. While Dylan stands by and does nothing, Siobhan intervenes, but the humiliated Erin declines her offer of a ride home. The next morning, Erin’s body is found in Sharp’s Woods. Mare delivers the tragic news to Kenny who breaks down in grief and immediately suspects Dylan. Mare questions Dylan, who denies involvement in Erin’s death.
Chief Carter holds a press conference, stating no official link exists between Erin’s murder and Katie Bailey’s earlier disappearance. Back at the station, Mare meets Detective Colin Zabel (Evan Peters), the young county detective assigned to the case. Although initially wary of Colin, whom she views as an outsider, Mare works with him to uncover video footage of Brianna attacking Erin in the woods. Mare arrests Brianna at her family’s restaurant, enraging her father Tony (Eric T. Miller). During questioning, Brianna refuses to speak without a lawyer and cruelly comments on Mare’s late son, Kevin.
Rising Stakes in Investigation
Something personal troubles Mare: Drew has developed a repetitive eye-blinking tic, the same tic Kevin exhibited before his mental health declined. Siobhan tells Mare she witnessed Brianna’s attack on Erin and tried to intervene, but Erin refused her help. Mare questions Dylan, who admits he was in the woods and saw Erin but insists they did not speak and that he left around midnight. Other teens confirm they saw Erin’s bike near the woods around 10 PM, but it had disappeared by midnight. None of them recalls hearing a gunshot. Erin’s phone was last tracked 12 miles from where her body was found, indicating she was killed at that location and her body moved to Sharp’s Woods.
The coroner’s report indicates Erin was killed between midnight and 2 AM, with no evidence of sexual assault. Notably, one of her fingers was severed by a gunshot. Her body had been redressed and relocated to mislead investigators. Overcome with grief, Kenny kidnaps Dylan at gunpoint and drives him into the woods, where he shoots him multiple times. Dylan survives but is seriously injured, and Kenny is subsequently arrested. Meanwhile, Jess reveals that Dylan is not DJ’s biological father and suspects Frank. Mare confronts Frank, who denies having a romantic relationship with Erin, explaining that he occasionally helped the struggling young mother with supplies out of kindness. He agrees to a DNA test and provides a solid alibi, stating he was at his engagement party, surrounded by numerous witnesses.
Mare’s investigation reveals Erin’s last phone call was to Deacon Mark Burton (James McArdle), the Catholic deacon and Erin’s older cousin. The deacon claims Erin called him upset but insists he was at the church rectory when the murder occurred. The investigation advances when Erin’s severed fingertip is found by a child in a remote park 12 miles from where her body was discovered. Searching the area, Mare discovers a bullet lodged in a tree, likely the one that passed through Erin’s finger. At the local festival, John becomes cold toward Mare after overhearing that she asked Frank to take a DNA test. He defends Frank, insisting Frank was with him the entire night of Erin’s murder and shows her a phone photo of Frank asleep at his house.
Colin receives an anonymous tip that Mark had been transferred from his previous parish over allegations of sexual misconduct with a minor. When Mare and Colin attempt to find him, he avoids them. Mare faces another crisis when she meets with Carrie Layden (Sosie Bacon), Drew’s birth mother and recovering heroin addict. Carrie announces she wants full custody of Drew. Mare, who is fiercely protective and skeptical of Carrie’s stability, refuses her request. Shaken by Carrie’s cruel claim that Kevin hated her and faced with the potential loss of Drew, Mare commits a serious breach of ethics: she steals heroin from the police evidence locker and plants it in Carrie’s car to sabotage her custody claim.
The Onset of Crisis
Explore More:
Meanwhile, Deacon Mark disposes of Erin’s distinctive pink bicycle, throwing it off a bridge into the river, setting off a chain of events that would soon unfold. The next morning, police arrest Carrie after an anonymous tip leads them to drugs found in her car. She insists the drugs are not hers. Chief Carter notices that the evidence bags match those missing from the police station. He immediately suspects Mare and confronts her. Mare is forced to surrender her badge and gun, resulting in her suspension.
DNA test results confirm that neither Dylan nor Frank is DJ’s biological father. Separately, Dawn receives a call from someone claiming Katie is alive and demanding USD 5,000 for her safe return. After her suspension, Mare must attend therapy sessions for potential reinstatement. Colin continues to work the cases, tracks down Deacon Mark, and confronts him about past allegations, which the deacon dismisses. Mare reads through Erin’s old social media posts—heartbreaking reflections about her love for her son that painfully remind Mare of her own experiences.
The town is shaken when Missy Sager (Sasha Frolova), a sex worker, is reported kidnapped. Mare seeks out Colin for information. He suspects Missy’s and Katie’s kidnappings are connected but believes they are separate from Erin’s murder, since Erin was not involved in sex work or heavy drug use. Mare wonders whether Erin might have briefly turned to prostitution to raise money for DJ’s surgery, but Colin notes this seems unlikely given the timeline and Erin’s known behavior.
Visiting Jess again, Mare learns that Erin had been reluctant to tell Dylan he was not DJ’s father because Dylan’s parents had been so supportive. Jess reveals that Erin had briefly created an online escort profile in a desperate attempt to raise money for the surgery but had never actually met anyone. Mare searches Erin’s house and finds a custom gold heart-shaped necklace engraved with the date of a family reunion, a potentially significant clue. Dawn follows the mysterious caller’s instructions to deliver ransom money, only to be mugged by Freddy Hanlon, who was exploiting her desperation. Shortly thereafter, a flashback reveals Katie Bailey’s fate: Missy’s kidnapper has also been holding Katie prisoner for over a year in a soundproofed room.
During a town-wide power outage, Lori overhears an anxious conversation between her husband, John, and son, Ryan, suggesting they share a troubling secret. Later, Lori tells Mare that Kenny had asked whether she and John would consider adopting DJ. Brianna realizes Dylan was not in bed with her for the entire night Erin was killed, and when she confronts him, he angrily forces her to leave. Ryan violently defends his sister Moira from a bully at school, then breaks down crying. When Lori comforts him, she assumes his distress stems from catching John cheating again, an assumption Ryan tearfully confirms. Believing Ryan’s tearful confirmation about John’s affair and devastated by what she perceives as repeated infidelity, Lori forces John to leave their home.
Unraveling the Fallout
Jess, Dylan, and Dylan’s friend, Sea (Sadat Waddy), visit Erin’s abandoned house. Jess retrieves her personal diaries and a stash of cash hidden within the radiator. She burns the diaries, an act she later explains was aimed at protecting Erin’s memory and honoring her wishes for DJ’s future by hiding the truth about his paternity. Meanwhile, Deacon Mark is attacked by local teens who are angry over rumors of past abuse allegations. Shaken by the attack, he confesses to Father Dan that he was with Erin the night she died. Erin had called him for a ride and appeared upset when he picked her up. He dropped her off at Brandywine Park after she received a text message instructing her to meet someone there.
Despite her suspension, Mare remains determined to pursue leads in an unofficial capacity. While investigating a possible link between Katie and Missy, Mare and Colin speak with Tammy (Rosa Arredondo), a former sex worker and Mare’s informant. Tammy reveals she was nearly abducted by a white man who smoked Winston cigarettes and drove an old blue work van, but managed to escape. Her account leads Mare and Colin to Wayne Potts (Jeb Kreager). At his remote house, they hear unsettling noises, and Mare investigates. Potts fires through the door, killing Colin instantly and wounding Mare. Despite her injury, Mare overpowers Potts, seizes Colin’s service weapon, and shoots him fatally. She finds Katie and Missy alive but traumatized in a soundproof attic room where they had been locked.
Deacon Mark admits to police that he panicked, tossing Erin’s bike into the river after her death out of fear that his involvement would make him a suspect. He is arrested for tampering with evidence. The kidnappings are confirmed to be unrelated to Erin’s murder since Potts has an alibi for that night. Following her bravery, Mare’s suspension is lifted. A ballistics expert matches the bullet found in a tree to a Colt Detective Special, a .38 caliber revolver once common among law enforcement but now rare.
Brianna shares new information with Mare and Chief Carter: Dylan was not with her for part of the night Erin was killed. Beth calls Mare, worried about Freddy. Mare finds him after an overdose. While there, she spots a T-shirt from the ‘Erin McMenamin Family Reunion,’ its date matching the engraving on the necklace. She questions Lori about the reunion, which was held at a lake cabin and attended by Lori’s family, Kenny, Erin, and John’s brother, Billy. Kenny confirms that he and Erin shared a cabin with Billy. Meanwhile, an armed Dylan threatens Jess, demanding that she disclose what she knows about DJ’s paternity.
John’s elderly father, Pat (Gordon Clapp), tells him he saw Billy return home late the night Erin died, distraught and covered in blood. John confronts Billy, who confesses to killing Erin and insists that he is DJ’s father. John relays this to Lori, then takes Billy on a fishing trip to the family cabin, intended as a final farewell before Billy turns himself in. Mare, having learned from a local jeweler that Billy had purchased Erin’s necklace, rushes to Lori’s house. Lori confirms John’s story and confirms that he took Billy fishing. Realizing something is wrong, Mare races to the cabin.
Breakthroughs That Shifted Everything
Fearing for her safety after Dylan’s threats, Jess goes to Chief Carter and hands over a photo she saved from Erin’s phone: an image of Erin in bed with John. She admits Dylan forced her to burn Erin’s diaries, but she secretly saved the photo. This evidence unequivocally reveals John—not Billy—as DJ’s father. Jess explains she destroyed the journals to honor Erin’s dying wish that DJ be raised by Dylan’s parents, who could offer a stable home. At the river, John’s real plan becomes clear—to kill Billy and stage it as a suicide. Billy, resigned to protecting his family by taking the blame, initially complies. As John prepares to shoot Billy and then himself, Billy hesitates and begins to struggle. Mare arrives just in time and manages to persuade John to surrender.
Back at the station, Mare is shown the photo and realizes John is not only DJ’s father but likely Erin’s killer. During interrogation, John admits that his affair with Erin began during the family reunion at the lake cabin. On the night of her death, Erin called, threatening to reveal their relationship unless he provided financial support. He claims Erin had a gun and was threatening suicide. He panicked while trying to take the gun, and it accidentally fired. He then called Billy to help dispose of the body. John is subsequently convicted and sentenced to prison. Meanwhile, Lori proceeds with adopting DJ and ensures he receives the ear surgery.
Mare becomes suspicious when she reviews John’s interrogation and hears him refer to Erin’s weapon as “some old pistol”. This vague language contradicts forensics that identified it as a police-issued Colt Detective Special. Glen Carroll (Patrick McDade) calls Mare with crucial information: his old service revolver had been missing from his locked shed but has reappeared with two bullets fired from it. He realizes only he and Ryan Ross, who occasionally did yard work for him, had access to the shed key. Mare obtains security footage from a neighbor’s camera showing Ryan sneaking out of the shed with the gun on the night of Erin’s death.
Mare heads to Ryan’s school, where he panics and flees home. Mare and Chief Carter follow and arrest Ryan at the Ross home. During questioning, Ryan breaks down and confesses. He had discovered his father’s affair with Erin and, on the night of Frank’s engagement party, saw threatening messages from her on John’s phone. Wanting to protect his family from falling apart again, Ryan posed as John and texted Erin, asking her to meet at Brandywine Park. He stole Glen’s gun, intending to confront Erin and scare her into silence to prevent her from destroying his family—a tragically naive plan for a thirteen-year-old that led to catastrophe. However, when they met, Erin became agitated and tried to grab the weapon. As they struggled, the gun fired and killed her instantly.
Ryan fled home and confessed everything to his father, prompting John to enlist Billy’s help in staging the cover-up. Lori later confesses to Mare that John revealed Ryan’s culpability to her following his arrest. Distraught but determined to protect her son, she had continued to lie about Billy. Though the shooting is ruled accidental, Ryan is still placed in juvenile detention. The case’s resolution shatters Mare’s town and fractures her closest friendship. In the final moments, Mare finally ascends into the attic where her son died—confronting the space she had long avoided since his suicide.
